Adeo Works

What Is a Red Team? Understanding the Role and Approach

While pentesters focus on individual vulnerabilities, a red team takes a much broader and more strategic approach to testing an organization’s security. A red team is a group of ethical hackers tasked with mimicking real-world adversaries, carrying out sophisticated multi-faceted attacks to assess an organization’s defensive measures, response protocols, and overall security posture. Red team exercises are designed to simulate what a real attacker would do, not just to find technical flaws but to see how well the organization’s overall defenses hold up under pressure.

Key Responsibilities of a Red Team

The role of a red team is far-reaching and involves several core responsibilities, beyond just technical testing. A red team simulates real-world cyberattacks by exploiting vulnerabilities and testing how well an organization can detect and respond to these attacks.

1. Simulate Real-World Attacks: Red teams conduct realistic cyberattacks that reflect the latest tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) used by actual threat actors. Unlike pentesters, who focus primarily on exploiting vulnerabilities in software or networks, red teams go after all aspects of security—physical, human, and technical. The aim is to reproduce the conditions of a highly skilled, determined adversary.
   • Phishing Campaigns: Red teams often deploy sophisticated phishing attacks to gain initial access to a system.
   • Malware Deployment: After gaining access, they may deploy malware to further exploit systems or establish persistence.
   • Social Engineering: Using deception, they may manipulate employees into disclosing sensitive information or granting physical access to secure areas.
2. Test Detection and Response: One of the key aspects of red team exercises is testing an organization’s ability to detect and respond to intrusions. Red teams assess whether an organization’s defense mechanisms—such as intrusion detection systems (IDS), firewalls, and anti-malware tools—are capable of detecting attacks. In addition, they also examine how well internal teams respond to security incidents and if they are prepared for real-world cyber threats.
   • Incident Response: During a red team engagement, the red team will often trigger alarms to see how quickly the internal security teams react. Are they able to isolate the threat in time? Do they follow proper procedures?
   • Security Monitoring: Red teams also check how well an organization’s Security Operations Center (SOC) is able to monitor activity and respond to potential attacks.
3. Test Organizational Resilience: Red teaming also focuses on the resilience of the entire organization, testing how well various teams (e.g., security, IT, and even management) respond under pressure. It isn’t just about finding weaknesses; it’s about creating an environment where security teams can improve their processes and procedures.
   • Crisis Management: Red teams simulate real-world attacks that force leadership teams to make decisions on the fly, testing both strategic thinking and operational efficiency.
   • Business Continuity: They often target core business functions and critical infrastructure to see how well the company can continue operations during a significant disruption.

Tools and Methodologies Used by Red Teamers

Red teams have a more diverse toolkit than pentesters, as their mission is broader and more complex. Tools can range from the latest social engineering tactics to advanced network exploitation techniques. Here are some tools and methodologies red teams use:

• Social Engineering: The ability to manipulate people into providing confidential information is crucial for red teams. Common tools and methods include:
  • Phishing: Using fake emails to trick employees into revealing credentials or downloading malicious software.
  • Pretexting: Creating a fake persona to gain access to sensitive information.
  • Baiting: Luring employees into clicking on malicious links or downloading infected files.
• Physical Security Penetration: Red teams often attempt to breach physical security as part of their attack simulations. This could involve:
  • Gaining unauthorized access to office spaces, data centers, or restricted areas.
  • Testing security measures like access control systems, security cameras, and guard protocols.
• Advanced Malware: When physical or social engineering efforts succeed, red teams may deploy malicious software (malware) to compromise a system, escalate privileges, or maintain persistence within the target network. They might use custom malware or commonly available exploit kits.
• Custom Attack Tools: Red teams often develop or use custom tools that allow them to evade detection and carry out specific attack simulations. Examples include:
  • Cobalt Strike: A tool used for post-exploitation and lateral movement.
  • Empire: A post-exploitation tool that leverages PowerShell to carry out attacks in Windows environments.

Red Team Engagement Duration and Complexity

Unlike pentesting, which is typically a short-term, focused engagement, red team exercises are longer and more involved. A red team engagement can last anywhere from a few weeks to several months, depending on the complexity of the test and the organization’s needs. Red teams don’t simply scan for vulnerabilities; they test the entire organization’s defense strategy, often without the knowledge of the target organization’s internal teams.

• Planning Phase: A red team engagement usually starts with detailed planning to define the scope, objectives, and rules of engagement. The planning process might involve creating a timeline, deciding on attack vectors, and determining how aggressive the tactics will be.
• Execution Phase: Once the attack simulation begins, the red team uses a variety of tools and methods to simulate a real-world attack. This phase can involve continuous attempts to breach multiple layers of the organization’s defenses.
• Reporting Phase: After the engagement concludes, the red team presents a comprehensive report. This report includes findings on how the attack unfolded, what vulnerabilities were exploited, how the organization responded, and recommendations for improving security measures and response capabilities.

Pentester vs Red Team: What’s the Difference?

At this point, we’ve defined both pentesters and red teams, explored their responsibilities, tools, and methodologies. So, how do these two roles compare, and what sets them apart?

Focus and Scope of Engagement

• Pentesters are generally focused on identifying specific vulnerabilities in a system, network, or application. They assess particular areas of an organization’s security to find weaknesses that could be exploited.
• Red teams, in contrast, have a broader scope. They aim to simulate a real-world attack that targets multiple layers of an organization’s defenses—technical, physical, and human. Their goal is to test the overall security of an organization, including its response procedures.

Goals and Objectives

• The goal of a pentester is to identify vulnerabilities and provide actionable steps to remediate them before a hacker can exploit them.
• The goal of a red team is to test an organization’s entire defense strategy, including detection, response, and recovery. A red team’s approach is more about testing resilience and organizational readiness.

Tools and Methodologies

• Pentesters rely heavily on automated tools like Nmap, Metasploit, and Burp Suite to scan for vulnerabilities and exploit them.
• Red teamers use a wider range of tools, including social engineering, advanced malware, and physical penetration techniques to mimic a real-world, multifaceted attack.

Duration and Complexity

• Pentests are typically short-term engagements, focused on identifying vulnerabilities within a specific system or network.
• Red team engagements are usually longer and more complex, testing a wide range of attack vectors over an extended period.

Outcome

• Pentester reports provide detailed lists of vulnerabilities and technical recommendations for remediation.
• Red team reports include comprehensive assessments of how the organization responded to multi-layered attacks and provide strategic recommendations for improving overall security.

When Does a Pentester Work as Part of a Red Team?

In some situations, a pentester may be part of a red team engagement. While the roles are distinct, there is overlap in the skills required, and a pentester’s technical expertise can add significant value to a red team’s efforts.

Overlapping Roles

A pentester’s ability to scan for vulnerabilities and exploit weaknesses can be invaluable during a red team operation. For example, if the red team has successfully gained access to an organization through social engineering or physical infiltration, the pentester can use their skills to escalate privileges or exploit additional vulnerabilities within the system.

Collaborative Engagements

In some cases, the pentester may take a supporting role within a larger red team operation. Red teams may rely on pentesters to conduct focused tests on specific systems or areas during the overall attack simulation.

Skills Required for Both Pentesters and Red Team Members

While pentesters and red team members have distinct roles, they share many core competencies, especially when it comes to understanding cybersecurity and the tactics used by attackers. However, their specific skill sets and knowledge diverge significantly in some areas, depending on the scope of their respective roles. Below, we’ll break down the key skills necessary for both pentesters and red team members to be successful in their work.

Skills for Pentesters

1. Technical Expertise in Cybersecurity: A pentester needs to be proficient in several technical areas of cybersecurity. These include:
   • Network Security: Understanding how to assess and test network infrastructures for weaknesses, such as misconfigured firewalls, vulnerable ports, and outdated software.
   • Web Application Security: Proficiency in web application vulnerabilities such as SQL injection, cross-site scripting (XSS), and cross-site request forgery (CSRF).
   • Operating System and Server Exploitation: Understanding the internal workings of operating systems (Linux, Windows) and how attackers exploit flaws in these systems.
2. Penetration Testing Tools and Techniques: Pentesters heavily rely on specialized tools and frameworks to perform their job. A skilled pentester will be familiar with:
   • Automated Scanners: Tools like Nessus or OpenVAS help automate vulnerability discovery and risk assessments.
   • Exploitation Frameworks: Tools like Metasploit and Burp Suite enable pentesters to exploit vulnerabilities once discovered.
   • Custom Scripting: Proficiency in scripting languages like Python, Bash, or PowerShell is essential to create custom exploits, scripts, and payloads.
3. Knowledge of Common Vulnerabilities: Pentesters need a deep understanding of common vulnerabilities found in different systems, such as the OWASP Top Ten for web application security. These vulnerabilities often form the basis of their testing and exploitation techniques.
4. Reporting and Communication Skills: Pentesters are responsible for producing clear, actionable reports for clients. This requires excellent communication skills, including the ability to explain complex technical findings in a way that non-technical stakeholders can understand.

Skills for Red Team Members

1. Broad Cybersecurity Knowledge: Red team members need to understand all facets of cybersecurity, as their mission involves attacking an organization’s entire infrastructure. This includes:
   • Advanced Malware Development: Knowledge of creating or modifying malware to avoid detection while achieving specific goals, such as persistence or lateral movement.
   • Social Engineering Tactics: In-depth understanding of human psychology and how to exploit it. This includes techniques like phishing, pretexting, and baiting.
   • Physical Security: Ability to infiltrate physical spaces, bypass security systems (e.g., card readers, security cameras), and gain unauthorized access to facilities.
2. Red Team-Specific Tools and Techniques: Unlike pentesters, who rely mostly on automated tools, red teamers use a wider range of resources. Key tools include:
   • Cobalt Strike: A post-exploitation tool that helps red teamers manage compromised systems and simulate real-world attack scenarios.
   • Empire: A PowerShell-based post-exploitation framework that helps red teamers move laterally within a network.
   • Social Engineering Tools: Red teamers may use custom phishing kits or SET (Social Engineering Toolkit) to craft tailored attacks targeting specific individuals or organizations.
3. Advanced Incident Response and Attack Simulation: Red teamers not only need to know how to break in but also how to assess the organization’s ability to detect and respond to attacks. This involves simulating advanced persistent threats (APT) and working with internal teams to measure how effectively they respond to:
   • Compromise Indicators: Identifying the presence of malware or other signs of compromise.
   • Lateral Movement: Moving between systems once access is gained, attempting to escalate privileges and deepen access.
4. Crisis Management and Strategic Thinking: A red team’s role is to evaluate how well the organization reacts under stress. Red teamers need to:
   • Think like a real-world attacker, constantly adapting their tactics and strategies to bypass security measures.
   • Simulate a full-scale attack, testing not only technical defenses but also decision-making and leadership under pressure.
5. Physical and Network Penetration: One unique skill for red team members is the ability to physically infiltrate a company’s premises or bypass network security using more sophisticated methods. This includes:
   • Bypassing Physical Security: Testing physical access controls such as badge systems, biometric scanners, and guards.
   • Advanced Network Manipulation: Red teamers often test the physical network infrastructure and use advanced methods like man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks to compromise communications.

Skills Overlap and Hybrid Roles

Both pentesters and red team members require strong problem-solving abilities, analytical thinking, and attention to detail. In fact, many of the skills that make someone successful in one role can often transfer to the other. For instance:

• Pentesters often use social engineering to gain initial access, and a red teamer can use automated tools to quickly assess vulnerabilities, but red team members generally need a broader skill set because their role includes complex, multi-layered attack strategies.
• Hybrid Roles: In smaller teams or companies, pentesters may take on a more red-team-like approach by adopting advanced tactics such as physical infiltration or social engineering to provide more comprehensive attack simulations.

For an individual looking to move from one role to another, gaining experience in areas outside of just technical exploitation—such as physical security, social engineering, or incident response—would be essential. Over time, a skilled pentester can develop the broader, more strategic thinking required to become a red team member.

Which One Should You Choose for Your Organization: Pentest or Red Team?

Now that we’ve explored the roles, tools, and skills required for both pentesters and red teams, the next logical question is: Which one should you choose for your organization? The answer depends largely on your organization’s security needs, risk profile, and maturity level in cybersecurity.

When to Choose a Pentester

You should choose a pentester if:

• You need a focused, technical assessment of your organization’s systems, networks, or applications.
• You have specific concerns regarding certain vulnerabilities that need to be addressed immediately (e.g., outdated software, misconfigured networks).
• You want a more budget-friendly option, as pentests are typically shorter engagements.
• You are looking to ensure compliance with specific industry standards (e.g., PCI-DSS, HIPAA, GDPR) that require regular vulnerability assessments.

When to Choose a Red Team

On the other hand, you should opt for a red team engagement if:

• You want a full-scale, multi-layered simulation of an attack that tests your organization’s entire security posture, not just specific vulnerabilities.
• You are looking to evaluate the organization’s incident response, detection capabilities, and overall readiness against sophisticated threats.
• Your organization has matured past basic vulnerability assessments and you need to test more complex attack vectors and resilience.
• You need to simulate real-world cyberattacks like those from advanced persistent threats (APT) or highly skilled hackers.

Combining Pentesting and Red Teaming for Comprehensive Security

In many cases, a hybrid approach—combining both pentesting and red teaming—may be the most beneficial. Organizations with complex security needs should start with a pentest to uncover vulnerabilities, and then move on to a red team engagement to test how well their defenses hold up under real-world attack scenarios. By using both, you get a multi-faceted approach to cybersecurity that provides both immediate technical remediation and long-term security improvement.

Real-World Use Cases: Pentesters vs. Red Teams in Action

We will explore real-world use cases to highlight how both pentesters and red teams work in practice. Each role plays a critical part in enhancing an organization’s overall security posture. By examining these case studies, you’ll get a better understanding of when to engage a pentester or a red team and what kind of outcomes you can expect from their involvement.

Example 1: Pentest Case Study – A Financial Institution

A financial institution hired a pentester to perform a penetration test on their web application and customer portal to assess the security of their online banking platform.

Scenario: The objective was clear: identify vulnerabilities within the platform that could potentially expose customer data or allow unauthorized transactions. The pentester focused on testing the application for common vulnerabilities such as:

• SQL Injection: The tester searched for input fields where database queries were vulnerable to injection attacks.
• Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): Ensured that user inputs did not allow malicious scripts to execute within a user’s browser.
• Broken Authentication: The pentester examined the authentication mechanism for flaws that could allow attackers to bypass login forms.

Findings:

• The pentester discovered several vulnerabilities, including an SQL injection in the login form and a misconfigured authentication system that allowed password brute-forcing.
• The pentester provided detailed remediation steps, including patching the SQL injection vulnerability and implementing multi-factor authentication to secure the login process.

Outcome: As a result, the financial institution was able to patch the vulnerabilities before any actual attackers could exploit them. The pentester’s role was critical in identifying specific vulnerabilities and providing clear, actionable recommendations for fixing them.

This case demonstrates how pentesters can play a vital role in securing specific systems and applications by identifying and mitigating vulnerabilities before they are exploited by malicious hackers.

Example 2: Red Team Case Study – A Technology Firm

A technology firm engaged a red team to assess its overall security infrastructure and test the effectiveness of its incident response protocols. The goal was to simulate a full-scale cyberattack, including physical, technical, and human elements.

Scenario: The firm wanted to ensure that not only their technical defenses (firewalls, IDS systems, etc.) were strong, but also that their internal teams—such as security personnel, IT support, and even executive leadership—could respond effectively to a sophisticated attack. The red team’s engagement was divided into several stages:

• Phase 1: Social Engineering: The red team began with a phishing campaign targeting employees to steal login credentials and gain initial access to the network.
• Phase 2: Internal Network Penetration: After gaining access through the phishing attack, the red team used lateral movement to compromise additional systems and escalate privileges within the internal network.
• Phase 3: Physical Penetration: Simultaneously, the red team attempted to breach physical security by gaining access to secure areas in the company’s data center, bypassing badge readers and tailgating employees into restricted areas.
• Phase 4: Attack Simulation: The red team conducted a full attack simulation, deploying malware and data exfiltration tactics to mimic an advanced persistent threat (APT).

Findings:

• The social engineering attack was highly successful, with several employees clicking on malicious links and handing over their login credentials.
• The red team was able to move laterally within the network undetected for over a week, accessing sensitive data and critical systems.
• The incident response team detected the intrusion only after the red team had already exfiltrated significant data. Their response was slow, and there was confusion around the escalation process.
• Physical security was weak, with the red team successfully gaining access to the building without raising alarms.

Outcome: While the company’s technical defenses were relatively strong, the response to the attack was slow and ineffective. The red team provided invaluable insights into improving incident detection, response protocols, and employee awareness. As a result, the technology firm:

• Strengthened their employee training around phishing and social engineering.
• Improved their incident response plan, ensuring clearer roles and faster action during a security event.
• Enhanced physical security measures by tightening access controls and enforcing stricter ID verification.

This case demonstrates the comprehensive nature of red teaming. It wasn’t just about finding technical vulnerabilities; the red team assessed the overall resilience of the organization’s people, processes, and technologies under the pressure of a real-world attack.

How to Get Started in Pentesting and Red Teaming

If you’re considering a career in pentesting or red teaming, it’s important to understand the skills and certifications required for each role. Both fields offer dynamic, challenging career paths in the rapidly growing field of cybersecurity.

For Aspiring Pentesters

If you want to pursue a career as a pentester, you should focus on building both practical experience and theoretical knowledge in cybersecurity.

1. Certifications:
   • OSCP (Offensive Security Certified Professional): One of the most respected certifications for pentesters, it focuses on hands-on skills and vulnerability exploitation.
   • CEH (Certified Ethical Hacker): Provides a broad overview of ethical hacking techniques, tools, and methodologies.
   • CompTIA Security+: A foundational certification for those just starting in cybersecurity.
2. Resources for Learning:
   • Capture the Flag (CTF) challenges: Participate in online platforms like Hack The Box or TryHackMe to practice penetration testing in controlled environments.
   • Books: Read books like The Web Application Hacker’s Handbook by Dafydd Stuttard and Marcus Pinto to deepen your understanding of web application security.
   • Tools and Environments: Familiarize yourself with pentesting tools like Kali Linux, Burp Suite, and Metasploit.
3. Practice and Labs:
   • Set up your own home lab to test vulnerabilities and practice different exploitation techniques.
   • Take part in bug bounty programs on platforms like HackerOne or Bugcrowd to gain real-world experience and earn money by finding vulnerabilities in publicly available systems.

For Aspiring Red Teamers

Becoming a red teamer involves a broader skill set than a pentester, as red team engagements are more complex and multifaceted.

1. Certifications:
   • OSCE (Offensive Security Certified Expert): A highly regarded certification for those who want to advance in red teaming, focusing on advanced exploitation and attack strategies.
   • CREST Certified Penetration Tester (CPT): A certification recognized by red teamers, demonstrating skills in advanced penetration testing and attack simulation.
   • Certified Red Team Professional (CRTP): A certification that focuses specifically on red team tactics and tools.
2. Additional Skills:
   • Physical Security Knowledge: Learning how to bypass physical security controls is essential for red teamers. Consider certifications like Certified Protection Professional (CPP) or training in physical penetration testing.
   • Social Engineering: Red teamers should be skilled in deception and manipulating human behavior. Understanding psychology and learning techniques like phishing, pretexting, and baiting will be crucial.
   • Advanced Networking and Malware: Red teamers must be familiar with advanced malware development, stealth techniques, and network manipulation.
3. Tools and Resources:
   • Familiarize yourself with Cobalt Strike, Empire, and other advanced red team tools.
   • Experiment with social engineering platforms such as SET (Social Engineering Toolkit) for phishing attacks.
4. Join Red Team Communities:
   • Participate in red team challenges and virtual labs on platforms like Red Team Village or Hack The Box.
   • Attend cybersecurity conferences such as Black Hat or DEF CON, where red team tactics and tools are often discussed.

Can a Pentester Become a Red Teamer?

For those who are currently working as pentesters and want to transition into red teaming, the transition is entirely feasible—but it requires gaining additional skills and experience in broader attack tactics.

1. Skills Overlap: Pentesters already possess strong technical skills, such as vulnerability assessment, exploitation, and scripting, all of which are essential for red teaming.
2. What You’ll Need to Learn:
   • Broaden your scope: Red teaming involves physical penetration, social engineering, and testing an organization’s overall security posture. You will need to learn how to approach an attack from multiple angles.
   • Incident Response and Management: Red teamers often play an active role in incident response, so learning how to work within and evaluate response teams will be important.
   • Attack Strategy: Think like a real-world attacker and develop advanced techniques such as lateral movement, data exfiltration, and avoiding detection.
3. Path to Red Teaming:
   • Consider gaining certifications specific to red teaming, such as the OSCE or CREST.
   • Participate in red team engagements through your current organization or as part of an external service.

By expanding your knowledge into these new areas, you can smoothly transition from pentesting to red teaming, giving you a broader set of tools and strategies for simulating advanced attacks.

Are Pentesters and Red Teamers the Same?

To wrap up, while pentesters and red teamers share some overlapping skills, they are distinct roles within cybersecurity. Pentesters focus on finding vulnerabilities and exploiting them to improve the security of a system, while red teamers take a broader approach, simulating full-scale, multi-layered cyberattacks to assess an organization’s overall security resilience.

• Pentesters are often focused on technical vulnerability assessments and exploitations, typically in a short-term engagement.
• Red Teamers, on the other hand, take a more strategic, longer-term approach to simulate real-world attacks, testing technical defenses and response processes.

Both roles are essential for a comprehensive cybersecurity strategy, and depending on the organization’s needs, you may require one or both. By understanding these differences, organizations can choose the right type of security testing for their specific objectives, helping them stay ahead of emerging cyber threats.